hamoun76

Majikoi has a high school setting with action, romance and comedy elements. Try it.

KonoSora, especially if you're itching to read something untranslated. While it actually is translated, the translation is terrible, but the game is great, so read the original Japanese version instead.

To Heart 2. High school, romance, 9 routes, 11 girls.

I¿d say Noble☆Works and Grisaia no Kajitsu

Good idea for a thread, i've been trying to find out myself a couple of song names from KoiChoco ( mainly the song when chisato confesses on most routes the unskipablle parts) and the Ost which i've already found but not the other one, so i appreciate this thread ^^

Are you talking about this song?
 

I recently picked up Miagete goran, yozora no hoshi o. Haven't done too much but I think it's pretty well fit for the criteria.

You should go for Kingdom Hearts Prime Edition

(KonoSora, Hoshimemo, and Princess Evangile)
 

Well, Princess Evangile is a great one. It's light, funny, has great art and its well written.
A few others that I think would be good:
https://vndb.org/v5240 Ikinari anata ni koishiteiru
https://vndb.org/v28 - Shuffle!
There is like 90000000 more that fits the criteria, but I'd at least consider those.
Grisaia no Kajitsu is fantastic, but do keep in mind that it has VERY heavy moments as well. So just be prepared for that.

Danganronpa
Grisaia no Kajitsu

Wow, I was just searching stuff myself and came up on this one. Thanks, will definitely try it, it looks good!
 
Kingdom Hearts has a visual novel? I remember playing it on the PS2 (Kingdom hearts 2) but didn't know it had a VN as well.

G senjou no mahou < really recomended.
 
and majikoi join us to the dark side of miyako route, com to the dark side com com little child... and cry.

Here's a few other threads that you should look at to help you decide what to play.
https://forums.fuwanovel.net/index.php?/topic/7166-romance-vn-recs/
https://forums.fuwanovel.net/index.php?/topic/6851-good-tearjerking-vns/
 
I personally would suggest CLANNAD but beware of the crappy translation

For romance I always suggest symphonic rain and Ef: a tale of the two.

yes

Only at first.  After you pass your seven hundredth heroine, it sort of becomes impossible to do that.

Nope, I do every route in every VN I read.  I'm a completionist, so I get seriously irked it I don't finish every route (except Isuzu's from Hoshimemo, I loathe her).  I don't really view it as "cheating" because each time you do a new route you're essentially back in the beginning of the story, and the events of the past route didn't actually happen.  I also don't really view it as a relationship between me and the heroine, only myself watching the MC develop a relationship with the heroine.  Even if I strongly identify with the protag I've never actually been able to "put myself in their shoes", so to speak, to the point where I think of myself as the protag.  Not to say that I don't form emotional attachments to the characters, though.
 
I'd seriously recommend reading the other routes in Hoshimemo.  Komomo and Kosame's routes kinda blow the other ones out of the water.

Loyalty. That's a good trait   

I tend to not worry too much about being 'faithful' to my ultimate bias heroine and just go ahead and play the other heroine routes.

Though I did have a visual novel withdrawal moment after I played my first VN, KonoSora. Like I felt bad that, in all technicalities, only one heroine will actually get to end up with the protagonist while the rest are GG'ed.

Then I played Steins;Gate and Bioshock: Infinite (both of which introduced the idea of multiple universes and alternate timelines) and from then on my philosophy is that ALL heroines get with the protagonist, it just happens on alternate timelines :3.

Edit: Oh yeah, and Rewrite is(semi-spoilers)

For this reason, I make sure to space out the time in which I play additional routes in a VN.

I don't read VNs for romance (in fact, I end up disliking 80% of the VN heroines I find) so this is kind of an alien concept to me. Still, interesting. 

I always do every single route in a VN,because i want to experience everything that a VN has to offer,and i just have to get that 100%
 
Then i read totono,and it changed the way i'll look at a VN for the rest of my entire life,so nowadays i actually feel kinda like i betrayed the heroine when doing other heroines routes after doing that particular one....
 
But what could i say? getting 100% gets the better of me every time

I wouldn't say I'm that type given the fact that obvious cheating from the protagonist can make me laugh and playing another route straight on doesn't bug me at all.

But I had that kind of feeling once, in Lucia's route (Rewrite). Dammit I never felt so involved, affected by a heroine than Lucia, her character is soo genuine that I can't possibly forget it, her past is astonishing and her development during the route turned me upside down to the point I didn't even took the time to play my usual role of sneaky bastard trying to pick minor flaws to criticize it just for the sake of it later (very mature of me indeed).
 
Now Lucia is my favorite heroine ever and I remember stalling Rewrite for a week after her route. I guess my answer is yes and no.

I usually only finish 1 route of any visual novel especially if the route I finished was very good/cute/romantic. One good example would be Asuho's route in Hoshizora no memoria. Seeing how much she was cute and the love that she had for the protagonist and the fact that  

just makes me feel like a traitor and a cheater If I play another girls route. Stupid, right?
 
So is there anyone out there like me who treats his 2D girls way too much like a real girl? LoL

I play as many routes as I can before I get tired of the game. I don't make commitments to any 2D girls
I always avoid the imouto route though...

I felt that way after completing some of Rewrite (Can't remember which route it was exactly - Kotori was first but I took an extended break after that) but eventually I powered on through and finished it.  There's nothing inherently wrong with it, it just means the writers are doing their job.  But the feeling only lasts a week or two at most, and if it left that strong of an impression you're likely to finish the game eventually.
 
I'm more likely to stop playing after a single route because the game managed to lose it's source of power, or if the path to the next route felt too convoluted (Ex.  Comyu, where it would auto-skip past the new scenes and severely hampered my enjoyment.)
 
It's a bit vague, but I suppose I am that type, at least in exceptionally good VNs.