Funnerific

Reading Lost:Smile reminded me of this thread. I think Meguru fits your criteria pretty well.

Ryou in Ikikoi - only in her route, however. See my review on VNDB for details.

Istoria, an (untranslated) VN with the best common route I've ever seen, comes to mind. Barely any "pointless" scenes and no boredom. Good interesting characters, including some depth for the protagonist. Not light- or warmhearted, but rather oppressively depressing throughout. However, you might want to avoid my thoughts on it if you don't want to be discouraged from reading the game.

Haruka Kanata (my kewl review) Ojou-sama Kumikyoku (my less kewl review) Also seconding Zaka's Mahou Shoujo rec.

Wdym =0? https://vndb.org/c/all?q=&fil=gender-f.trait_inc-74~1192.tagspoil-0.role-primary https://vndb.org/c/all?q=&fil=gender-f.trait_inc-74~1307.tagspoil-0.role-primary https://vndb.org/c/all?q=&fil=gender-f.trait_inc-74~1504.tagspoil-0.role-primary https://vndb.org/c/all?q=&fil=gender-f.trait_inc-74~1683.tagspoil-0.role-primary And in response to your last question, if I understand you correctly and you want a heroine who is treated by the game as MC and has a lot of parts from her PoV and choices, https://vndb.org/v5746

https://vndb.org/c/all?q=&fil=gender-f.trait_inc-74.tagspoil-0.role-primary PROTIP: Do not click on names which don't have the game name to the right. Those are walking spoilers for their game.

I haven't played RWA, but your description of the protag reminds me of G-senjou no Maou.

Hikaru, chaotic good? You can't be serious, she's totally lawful good. The other two do indeed fit quite a bit, thanks to the game avoiding the obligatory "no killing allowed" JP trope. From me, I can only recommend Mahou Shoujo, though not for a heroine. The female MC is an incredibly based individual that also fits the chaotic good alignment. There are other reasons to recommend it, too...

Wanting Wings and Faraway Feathers isn't exactly a double package because even in the JP release the sequel contains the original game in its entirety.

Ayakashibito has this.

"However, if you were to show it to a real adventurer... They would shout in anger about how naive and convenient this story is."

Appreciate the explanation. I was new to Japanese at the time so I probably missed it. This sure is late though wow.

https://vndb.org/v/all?q=&fil=tag_inc-900.tagspoil-0&rfil=&cfil=&s=title&o=a

Kotori is pretty unique, so it's a really hard request... I think my best suggestion would be https://vndb.org/c11642 Not energetic/cheerful, but should fit the other criteria. Sorry if I missed the mark.