Jump to content

Mr Poltroon

Administrators
  • Content count

    5,828
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    47

Reputation Activity

  1. Like
    Mr Poltroon reacted to Dreamysyu in Stories that surpass the original premise   
    Well, Boku Girl starts as your typical fanservice genderswap manga, but the later half doesn't really have much fanservice at all, and turns into more "understanding yourself" kind of manga. Though, I guess, it's pretty standard for more modern gender benders.
    If we count LNs (though there's a manga adaptation too), there's a recent license by Seven Seas, The Saint's Magic Power is Omnipotent. The general premise sounds like some kind of generic isekai story. Two girls get summoned to another world, one of them is named a saint, while the other is basically left to her own devices, while in reality is actually the second girl who is the saint. The whole thing actually gets resolved pretty quickly, and what I personally like about this series is that it doesn't try to make the other party look ridiculously evil, like many other novels like that do.
    Can't really think about anything else, though I may remember something else if I think about it.
  2. Like
    Mr Poltroon reacted to Daydreamer97 in What are you playing?   
    I've been reading another indie otome called Dark Nights. It's like Cinderella Phenomenon in the sense that it's a high-quality medium-length indie vn which probably should have cost money but is free. It's also something I've been looking forward to for years because the art is really pretty and Pinlin, the solo dev who worked on it is seriously talented and her art is absolutely gorgeous. So far, I'm only on my first route but it's been doing a good job at setting this horror tone and a multi-route mystery.
    I also played another free-but-should-have-been-commercial indie I've been looking forward to- Ebon Light. There are love interests but it's not a traditional otome (although I do count it as one) because the romance is more of a side thing than the main thing. It's more plot-focused and is a little more game-y with stats. It also has beautiful western-style art and a dark fantasy aesthetic which really kept me hooked. You get to shape the MC's personality in this one so there's a lot of branches and ways to get a good ending.
  3. Like
    Mr Poltroon reacted to Fiddle in Stories that surpass the original premise   
    Others may disagree, but I've always believed Attack on Titan has a profoundly dumb premise, like it was pulled from a weird nightmare somebody had after sleeping for 10 hours. But somehow it turns into something amazing*.
    *this is probably the part that others will disagree with.
  4. Like
    Mr Poltroon reacted to TexasDice in Musicus: Is this or Mangagamer still relevant   
    Aside from titles/companies someone has heard of before?
    How about titles that have some basic features I'd expect from a VN in 2020, like voice lines playing over mouse click or free button mapping. Even the one-voice-actress, reused-bgm nukige Ammolite keeps shitting out manage to fulfill those requirements. 
    But yes, what it boils down to most is the complete lack of any big name that gets people exited. I like Newton, Under One Wing is fine and Oniikiss is a pretty decent nukige. However, these games as well as the by now infamous Sakura Sakura are the epitome of "literally who?"-games. Which is a shame, since the Sol tech-whizzes responsible for decensoring and upscaling those 2008-resolutions are committing what I can only assume is black magic.
    which leads me to... 
    They are similar, but that isn't exactly the problem. Nekonyan scored a well-known publisher in addition to their "literally-who"-games. Nobody cared at all about Fureraba when it released. I assume no English VN reader ever heard of it before or cared much. Now, quite a while later, lots of people (me included) were RAVING for Making Lovers to come out and put the Smee name out there. That's the two-step plan: Lure the masses in with a big name (in this case Sanoba Witch) first and when they decide to stay, they'll check out the rest of your catalog.
    MangaGamer was, as far as I understand, able to get away with completely niché games from their initial Overdrive repertoire because a) There was no real competition and b) most of the initial footing was based on nukige and cheap porn games before Da Capo landed in their laps. And even then, we are now seeing that MG is running out of things people want to see, though I do appreciate their idea behind releasing some non-standard VNs recently.
    I'm not saying Sol Press is completely hopeless in this area, considering they managed to snatch Favorite, due to SP's utter lack of business sense, management and well... anything worth of basic praise. So if Sol can succeed with Iroseka, maybe those who cared about that will be more open to read - god forbid actually buy - Sakura Sakura. 
  5. Like
    Mr Poltroon got a reaction from Plk_Lesiak in Spring 2020 Anime Discussion   
    Here's a little update on that topic, @Dreamysyu.
    As of episode 5, I am actually of the opinion that the anime is better. Whereas the strength of the Light Novels is in entering a character's head outside of Catarina, the anime finds way of making a lot of this content into events that actually take place in Catarina's presence. From what I'm seeing, it involves giving roles to characters that previously didn't have any in a given part, which is great. Better still is the fact that it's not like it doesn't dive into backstory when it wants to, so it's the best of both worlds, in my opinion. Also seeing the characters being cute is fantastic.
    My initial reservations regarding the pace of the first few episodes (there were no transitions between scenes!) ended up being because they were trying to reach the school phase within the three episodes, so they cut transitions rather than rush the scenes they covered. A few scenes were rushed, but it's calmed down since.
  6. Like
    Mr Poltroon got a reaction from Plk_Lesiak in Spring 2020 Anime Discussion   
    Here's a little update on that topic, @Dreamysyu.
    As of episode 5, I am actually of the opinion that the anime is better. Whereas the strength of the Light Novels is in entering a character's head outside of Catarina, the anime finds way of making a lot of this content into events that actually take place in Catarina's presence. From what I'm seeing, it involves giving roles to characters that previously didn't have any in a given part, which is great. Better still is the fact that it's not like it doesn't dive into backstory when it wants to, so it's the best of both worlds, in my opinion. Also seeing the characters being cute is fantastic.
    My initial reservations regarding the pace of the first few episodes (there were no transitions between scenes!) ended up being because they were trying to reach the school phase within the three episodes, so they cut transitions rather than rush the scenes they covered. A few scenes were rushed, but it's calmed down since.
  7. Like
    Mr Poltroon reacted to MaggieROBOT in VNs with heroines who drink alcohol too   
    Shining Song Starnova, I guess. 
    Mariya starts the game as a alcoholic, Julie asks the MC out for drinks in 2 different occasions and all 7 girls go out to a bar with the MC to celebrate something at least once iirc 
  8. Like
    Mr Poltroon reacted to Plk_Lesiak in Musicus: Is this or Mangagamer still relevant   
    Yup, as @Mr Poltroon said, but I'd argue this undersells MGs importance. They're a company with a particularly diverse offering and one that is very consistent with their releases. They also tackle projects that no sane company should be willing to take, like translating Rance X (which is an absurdly large and complex game). While you have companies like NekoNyan focusing purely on moege, Sekai Project trips on its own legs every other month and JastUSA is lost in its own dimension where the timeflow doesn't follow the rules of our universe, MG gets stuff done. Right now, while there's generally more competition on the market and some developers, like Key and Frontwing, translate and publish their VNs in-house, it might not seem that important, but I think it still is. If MG suddenly disappeared, we would feeel it, particularly when it goes to more ambitious/niche VNs reaching the West. So, even though their image definitely suffered through all this drama, they're kind of indispensable and when they take on a project, you can be fairly sure it'll get done unless something really unusual happens.
  9. Like
    Mr Poltroon reacted to ArgentstR in Musicus: Is this or Mangagamer still relevant   
    Mangagamer releases an VN that interests me, I buy it just as always.
    On the points in that thread.
    Dude can definetely work as a TL in the right circumstances but it was kinda blanket TLd which isn't really optimal, the pressure the translator felt could probably have contributed to forgoing a more nuaced approach.
    Lot's of TL criticisms are rather uninformed imo, when people kick up a fuss about a noun -> noun TL choices and then point to some stilted TL that include all their favorite Japanisms but bungle the JP grammar and context in ways that completely change what's being said at points as "how a good TL is done" it becomes somewhat hard to take them seriously.
    I mean if it wasn't framed as some crusade against the evil "localization" conspiracy so often and people presented their questions in a more open manner it would be fine I guess.
    On the working conditions point, that is concerning but it's extremely hard to judge from the outside though, so I'm just hoping that things resolves in a way that no one gets screwed over.
    On the discord stuff, I just think people are being divas and should calm down and not be so easily offended.
    And on the Fatamoru stuff, outrage outlet saw lots of easy add money to be made and whipped up people who have no idea what they are talking about into an fit.
  10. Like
    Mr Poltroon got a reaction from Dreamysyu in Musicus: Is this or Mangagamer still relevant   
    Uh, yes they are. As much as anybody else.
    They translate titles into English and that's that. Not much else really matters, despite what loud vocal minorities might claim.
    Somebody having problems with translations has always been common and underpayment is supposedly getting better but Mangagamer is terrible in that area and for that they deserve all the flak.
    That all said, as long as they put out titles people who want translated VNs will get them, regardless of the company. Some boycotters exist, but not really a majority and given the piracy levels I'm not sure how much overlap there is between the "boycotters" and the pirates.
    From the Japanese side they're well placed with headquarters in Japan and, considering the Japanese side often is unaware of the quality of translations (Hello SakuraGame), Mangagamer likely does not have problems landing deals on that front.
     
    So, all in all, I'm not sure I understood what you're trying to say. As long as they have money and they continue to want to translate titles, they will do so.
  11. Like
    Mr Poltroon got a reaction from Dreamysyu in Musicus: Is this or Mangagamer still relevant   
    Uh, yes they are. As much as anybody else.
    They translate titles into English and that's that. Not much else really matters, despite what loud vocal minorities might claim.
    Somebody having problems with translations has always been common and underpayment is supposedly getting better but Mangagamer is terrible in that area and for that they deserve all the flak.
    That all said, as long as they put out titles people who want translated VNs will get them, regardless of the company. Some boycotters exist, but not really a majority and given the piracy levels I'm not sure how much overlap there is between the "boycotters" and the pirates.
    From the Japanese side they're well placed with headquarters in Japan and, considering the Japanese side often is unaware of the quality of translations (Hello SakuraGame), Mangagamer likely does not have problems landing deals on that front.
     
    So, all in all, I'm not sure I understood what you're trying to say. As long as they have money and they continue to want to translate titles, they will do so.
  12. Like
    Mr Poltroon got a reaction from Dreamysyu in Musicus: Is this or Mangagamer still relevant   
    Uh, yes they are. As much as anybody else.
    They translate titles into English and that's that. Not much else really matters, despite what loud vocal minorities might claim.
    Somebody having problems with translations has always been common and underpayment is supposedly getting better but Mangagamer is terrible in that area and for that they deserve all the flak.
    That all said, as long as they put out titles people who want translated VNs will get them, regardless of the company. Some boycotters exist, but not really a majority and given the piracy levels I'm not sure how much overlap there is between the "boycotters" and the pirates.
    From the Japanese side they're well placed with headquarters in Japan and, considering the Japanese side often is unaware of the quality of translations (Hello SakuraGame), Mangagamer likely does not have problems landing deals on that front.
     
    So, all in all, I'm not sure I understood what you're trying to say. As long as they have money and they continue to want to translate titles, they will do so.
  13. Like
    Mr Poltroon reacted to Dreamysyu in Spring 2020 Anime Discussion   
    Actually, wait.
     
  14. Like
    Mr Poltroon reacted to Dreamysyu in Spring 2020 Anime Discussion   
    I see. The truth is, she hasn't even appeared in the story in the 3 episodes that I watched, but a certain scene from the opening made me suspicious. Also, I guess this web-novel I've been following actually is a total ripoff of Bakarina.
    Also, I don't particularly care about minor spoilers for this one.
  15. Like
    Mr Poltroon got a reaction from Dreamysyu in Spring 2020 Anime Discussion   
    My opinion on the first couple of novels:
    Let me preface by saying that the best thing about the story, its wholesomeness, also results in a lot of repetitiveness.
    Bakarina's inner thoughts are as simple as she is, obviously, so they're always the same things and the same misunderstandings. Her motivations are always the same and she always interprets everyone's actions from her own perspective, meaning, as far as inner thoughts go, every situation is the same in her head.
    Secondly, the interactions between the other characters are also repetitive and always the same.
    I think these aspects can be exponentially better in the anime, but I haven't actually watched it to confirm. It feels like these running gags will flow better in something more fast-paced and with complementary animation.
    Then there is the story. The events that occur. I don't see any reason why the anime would be particularly worse in that respect. It should have more than enough time to depict the events, because I, at least, didn't feel there were many of them outside of all the running gags and Bakarina being a baka.
    The only thing the novel might have over the anime, but again I have not seen it, are the scenes where the novel gets into a character's head
    The wholesomest of things. I'm not sure how they'd do this in the anime.
  16. Like
    Mr Poltroon got a reaction from Templarseeker in Download vngame or eroge   
    ^These are most of the VN sellers. If you search a name you should come across their stores or be redirected to steam.
  17. Like
    Mr Poltroon reacted to Seraphim88 in What are you playing?   
    Something must've gone wrong, but it should work now!
  18. Like
    Mr Poltroon got a reaction from Jardic47 in Old School Anime Recommendations?   
    These are the ones I remember watching, but I don't think they're particularly obscure, and are more likely just the opposite.
    Irresponsible Captain Tylor -> https://myanimelist.net/anime/569/Musekinin_Kanchou_Tylor
    Crest of the Stars (this barely meets the cut-off point) -> https://myanimelist.net/anime/290/Seikai_no_Monshou
    Slayers -> https://myanimelist.net/anime/534/Slayers
  19. Like
    Mr Poltroon reacted to Sonicboom2.0 in Inuyasha Sequel Manga In The Works!   
    I was so excited that I wanted to share this because Inuyasha was a huge part of my childhood and the reason I got into anime in the first place that I wanted all of you to know so I'll be posting the video on here that is reliable when it comes to anime news. Hopefully there's a lot of Inuyasha fans on here!
    Inuyasha Sequel Manga in Progress!
  20. Like
    Mr Poltroon got a reaction from Jardic47 in Old School Anime Recommendations?   
    These are the ones I remember watching, but I don't think they're particularly obscure, and are more likely just the opposite.
    Irresponsible Captain Tylor -> https://myanimelist.net/anime/569/Musekinin_Kanchou_Tylor
    Crest of the Stars (this barely meets the cut-off point) -> https://myanimelist.net/anime/290/Seikai_no_Monshou
    Slayers -> https://myanimelist.net/anime/534/Slayers
  21. Like
    Mr Poltroon reacted to Novel21 in So I Bought a Switch   
    Thats good to hear and i hope you enjoy playing Fire Emblem Three House. I'm going to play it tomorrow since I'm busy watching TV right now. 
    By the way congrats with new Nintendo Switch
  22. Like
    Mr Poltroon reacted to mitchhamilton in So I Bought a Switch   
     
    i will definitely play it then
  23. Like
    Mr Poltroon reacted to Silvz in So I Bought a Switch   
    I haven't played it yet, but it is pretty much a consensus that it is one of if not the best Fire Emblem ever
  24. Like
    Mr Poltroon reacted to Novel21 in So I Bought a Switch   
    I love Fire Emblem Three House, it's my favorite game and I really enjoy play it a lot. I recommend it a lot. So I recommend to give it a try:)
     
  25. Like
    Mr Poltroon reacted to mitchhamilton in So I Bought a Switch   
    speaking of fire emblem, been eyeing fire emblem three houses. what are your/peoples thoughts on that game?
     
    would love to play some bayonetta 2 so may look at that one. forgot all about it tbh.
×