Persona Best and Worst Girl: Poll and Discussion

[Stray Cat]

So, I figure enough people have played Persona and it's always fun to have this discussion.  Also, if you're willing, talk about why you chose who you did.  

[RinXD]

Flat is justice

[Stray Cat]

Flat is justice

[RinXD]

You obviously cant tell trolling from seriousness.

 

And I choose her cause something about her face shape and personality

[Lambda]

Mitsuru the Queen is my choice 10/10 would be her. I strive to be as strong as she is... Goals. Naoto and Fuuka come close, but the topic is about Best Girl, not Best Girls. That would be cheap!

 

Best Guy is Ryoji without question. Second is Theo tied with Teddie, then Shinjiro...  P3's guys are helped by the fact that P3P lets you date them, so... I did also love Adachi and Kanji.

[Stray Cat]

I decided to add a Worst Girl poll as well for fun.  

[Aniki]

Elizabeth is the undisputed best girl of all of Persona.

 

 

Noncanon, though, Minako is the undisputed best girl. 

 

[Stray Cat]

Elizabeth is the undisputed best girl of Persona.

[Aniki]

I loved Elizabeth for her humor, charm and devotion to the P3 MC.  Fuuka and Rise are also way up there.

[Stray Cat]

Indeed. I've only played P3, so I only know part of the story, yet I felt Elizabeth was the only one truly willing to do anything for the MC.

From what I've read too, that devotion continued for a long while.

 

Noncanon, though, Minako is the best one.

[EldritchCherub]

I'll go with Mitsuru, the icy queen. Her calm nature and subdued personality makes her a tough cookie to crack but a worthy endeavor, nevertheless. As for worst girl, I had trouble deciding between Yukari and Marie. I ultimately went with Marie cause her tsundere attitude didn't work as well as I thought it would and every time I saw one of her poems I was like 'here we go again.'

 

I'll wait to see if the vote goes in Chie's favor since she already has her own church and worshippers.

 

http://www.reddit.com/r/churchofchie

[Deep Blue]

Chie FTW (with the original english voice)

[solidbatman]

No Persona or Persona 2 love from op? Get the fuck outta here. All of you casual plebs. Ginko/Lisa and Maya are leagues better than any characters in Persona 3 or 4. 

[Lewycool]

Rise worst girl.

[Ram_Ram_A]

Akihiko is best persona 

[phersu]

Naoto Shirogane is best girl overall.

 

[Yeah Way]

 

Eriko, I fucking love you.

 

Seeing how she's not on the list, however, I'll settle for Elizabeth. After all, she's the only one trying to save Makoto's poor arse up there. :/

 

Worst defo goes to Chie. People call Yukari a bitch, but at least she's still a normal human being. Everything Chie does just irritates me. Her slapstick humour, her constant shouting, and she's just not cute. 

[Cyrillej1]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PjetzqJnblQ

Yessss, Naoto is winning!!   Lol, I love those skits... now I wonder what Rise saw xD

[Stray Cat]

I'll go with Mitsuru, the icy queen. Her calm nature and subdued personality makes her a tough cookie to crack but a worthy endeavor, nevertheless. As for worst girl, I had trouble deciding between Yukari and Marie. I ultimately went with Marie cause her tsundere attitude didn't work as well as I thought it would and every time I saw one of her poems I was like 'here we go again.'

 

I'll wait to see if the vote goes in Chie's favor since she already has her own church and worshippers.

 

http://www.reddit.com/r/churchofchie

Yea, I'm surprised she's doing so bad and Yukiko is doing so well.  The rest is about what I'd expect. 

[Cyrillej1]

I think I like Naoto, because although she's similar to Mitsuru in seriousness.. she doesn't seem to appear as 'bitchy/harsh' xD.

Her androgynous appearance looks cool to me and I like her boy-ish personality even though she's a girl.

 

Oh, and I chose Ai as worst..  honestly, I don't remember the extra girls much.. but if I remember correctly, I chose her only because she valued appearance/fashion so much.  Which is boring to me.

[Totodile]

 

 

I loved Elizabeth for her humor, charm and devotion to the P3 MC.  Fuuka, Mitsuru and Rise are also way up there.  I hated Ayane and her S. Link made me want to smash my Vita.  Yukari just constantly acts rotten and superficial so I can't stand her.  

[RinXD]

Yessss, Naoto is winning!!   Lol, I love those skits... now I wonder what Rise saw xD

if only we knew

[Deep Blue]

I kinda feel bad for saying this bad I love nanako (not in the same way i love chie ) she reminds me to my little nephew

 

http://youtu.be/R6EJoeVrdEw?t=5m40s

 

:wahaha:

[Lambda]

I kinda feel bad for saying this bad I love nanako (not in the same way i love chie ) she reminds me to my little nephew

 

http://youtu.be/R6EJoeVrdEw?t=5m40s

 

:wahaha:

Nanako was too adorable. She made getting back home after a long day of... whatever the protag was doing better. "Welcome home big brother!" Aaah such a cute little sister!~ My little brother should take notes!

[EldritchCherub]

"Everyday's great at your Junes~"

 

She should be the store's mascot, store would sell out thanks to cuteness overload!