What is a "good" H-scene.

[Kanbe]

I would say h-scenes that are really impactful to the story or relationship with the heroine. Other then that if it's worthy fap material for you, then I guess that's considered good too?

 

...also I prefer kyonyuus over flatties (forgive me kanasuke...)

[bogdankl]

can any1 give me a translated vn with some bad h scenes?

 

there's only 2 instances of h scene skipping i did

 

1. the first time i stumbled across one and that was when i played katawa <my first vn, hanako route> for some reason, even tho i knew it was in there and was waiting for it, i don't know why but when they started fking i was just like... 'this does not feel the way i was expecting it' <much guilt was felt that day>, i kinda really loved hanako and when i got at the end that scene turned 10x more bitter

2. nekopara, jesus fking christ was that bad, the whole "she's in heat" and "i'm only doing it cuz i'm worried" thing really stepped on my nerves for some reason and i didn't wanna see it <even tho the art and animation were pretty good i think>, also i might have something against cat-girls <maybe it's cuz i am a cat person>

 

so in short, bad writing, after all you are usually playing a vn for a while before you stumble across a h scene so you get kinda attached to a character, imagine if in g senjo no maou

kyouske actually raped usami when she came to him, or think about the bad ending of mizuha didn't read it but i did get the cg and it kinda shook me

[BobJones2]

The only "good" VN sex scenes (in that it gets me aroused) are the hardcore senseless fetish sex scenes from purely sex-focused VNs. In VNs where the focus is the plot, the sex scenes are too "normal" to get me aroused and even if there were to be fetishes in there that would usually turn me on, I would care too much about the plot and characters that it would acutally be a negative.

 

That's not to say I don't like sex scenes in story-focused VN, their inclusion adds a "sweetness" factor to the story, regardless of the actual content of the scenes. There are some few games where I really enjoy the conversations during sex, such as in Crescendo, where they poetically express their love beyond just typical sex lines.

 

I don't really understand all these complaints about how sex scenes should only be in there if they "advance" the plot. In fact, it would actually feel more forced if it did advance the plot, as if the writer came up with this little plot device just as an excuse to add in sex scenes. Fate/Stay Night for example. People have sex when they are in love, simple as that, the game is just showing us some scenes for those moments. If you don't like it, you can just skip it.

so in short, bad writing, after all you are usually playing a vn for a while before you stumble across a h scene so you get kinda attached to a character, imagine if in g senjo no maou

kyouske actually raped usami when she came to him, or think about the bad ending of mizuha didn't read it but i did get the cg and it kinda shook me

i don't see a lot of people fapping to that
 

Right, like I said, many popular fetishes (such as rape, meet-n-fucks, NTR, ugly dudes, or even harem) don't really work in plot-focused work, where you care too much about the characters, their relationships, and what happens to them. Even sexual harems don't work. Yes there are a lot of popular harem VNs where the MC goes around fucking everybody but virtually none of these are praised for having spectacular plots. In fact, having a spectacular plot could be detrimental.

[MoeKyun]

One that you can fap to.

Preferably animated CGs

And background voices

~~

Story wise pls develop the romance properly instead of the whole sex within 24 hours of confessing to each other

^ this

[wyldstrykr]

first of all, i dont like rape and the like

also too much h-scene ruins the game (if you want h-scene so badly, why just grab some porn videos or something and not read it)

 

i like h-scenes that confirms love for each other good cg, and good acting. also it is better to put the h-scene at the near end of the game (that gives a sense or reward to reader or player (?))

 

thats my opinion, feel free to disagree

[Rabbit]

I usually prefer it to be there to get the story going but if it's nukige than I don't care too much for the story.

 

In general i'd prefer it to have decent CG and good voice acting, I also need both parts to enjoy themselves.