Jump to content

Arch-Magos

Members
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    6

  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Posts posted by Arch-Magos

    Bad Endings?

    in Visual Novel Talk

    Posted · Edited by Down
    Spoiler tags please. Even for light spoilers.

    I think I can classify bad endings into three types, at least in my view of things - 

    --"Classic" Bad endings, IE endings that obviously indicate to the player - YOU FUCKED UP! The severity of the fuck up may vary from 'being cannibalized' to 'turned into a doll and used as a plaything by a loli' to 'You don't get to stick your dick in her.' depending on the game.

    --"Possible" Bad endings, IE endings that very well could simply end a route on it's own (and may in fact be indicated as such that they aren't really bad ends), though they aren't one of the primary route endings.

    --"Actual End" Bad endings, IE endings that wrap up a storyline and are considered better than a bad ending but really aren't.

     

    Now, examples as to all

     

    As to the first, I have to look at GnK, specifically the Makina bad end.

    You know, the one with fucking bag. That fucking bag. You know if you've played it which bag I'm talking about.

     

    To the second, I have to give this one to Mind of Steel end from Fate/Stay Night. It's a rather simple bad end that may not in fact be a bad end in another route. It could easily have been one of it's route endings (And indeed some in the fanbase would prefer it over the True end.) Another excellent example of this is from F/SN as well, the Sparks Linear High end. 

     

    When it comes to the third, the one that initially jumps to my mind is Ahika's Normal Ending from Tsukihime

    - the protagonist and his sister live... but it's pretty obvious they won't for long. One or the other will die, and the survivor is likely to commit suicide, or be killed by Kohaku. 

    H-Scenes. Really necessary?

    in Visual Novel Talk

    Posted

    Ah, H-Scenes.

     

    Am I the only one who sees them as comic relief?

     

    On topic, no. Can they make sense in context? Yes. Should they be included? As a purist I must grudgingly admit 'yes' to this, missing out on content originally meant to be shipped with the game just rubs me the wrong way, even if it's content I don't particularly have an interest in. For the most part I skip through H scenes, or read them to laugh.

     

    Translators, my heart goes out to you, I cannot imagine keeping a straight face through half of the dialog or sound effects.

×
×
  • Create New...