Jump to content

New VN localization company: MoeNovel


sanahtlig

  

83 members have voted

  1. 1. Will you buy MoeNovel's debut title, "If my Heart had Wings"

    • Yes
      10
    • No
      31
    • Maybe
      24
    • Depends if there is H or not
      18

This poll is closed to new votes


Recommended Posts

With no fanfare, a company calling itself MoeNovel has launched a website and plans to release its first title by the end of May. The title is "If my Heart had Wings", a highly regarded 2012 VN from acclaimed developer Pulltop. A demo of the game is available on their website. Pre-orders are available for US $35 on PlayAsia. According to VNDB, the title is long and offers 30-50hrs of gameplay. The English release will have the H-scenes removed to "reach a wider audience".

If_My_Heart_Had_Wings_303943.1.jpg

News as of 5/14/2013:

MoeNovel is the newest localization company to enter the market. The company appears to have connections to Active Gaming Media and Will, Pulltop's parent company.

VNTLS MoeNovel news summary: http://vntls.org/news/

MoeNovel's debut title will be "If My Heart Had Wings" or KonoSora (http://vndb.org/v9093), one of Pulltop's most successful story-driven titles, and is slated for release at the end of June 2013. The original title was winner of 3rd place in the 2012 Bishoujo Game Awards, and ranked 4th place for Scenario. News that the English release will be all-ages (no such version exists in Japanese) has attracted criticism.

Summarizing currently known information from the closed VNDB discussion of this title (http://vndb.org/t4066):

Content rating: The game has received a rating of T from the ESRB and 12 from PEGI.

Demo and translation quality: MoeNovel has released a demo. The translation is questionable and probably performed by a non-native English speaker: it appears to be accurate, mostly grammatically correct, yet very awkward. MoeNovel claims the script is still undergoing editing, and the final product should be more polished than the demo.

Overall content edits: The game's art will have to be heavily edited. The original game had 17 H-scenes and 5 heroines (2 of which are twins). Shini's count of the game's CG are as follows (note that these counts include variations of the same base CG):

Non-H: 463 (includes swimsuits, wet t-shirt with bra showing through, scene where it looks like a girl has nopan)

Ero: 646 (includes CGs that are part of H scenes and bath scenes with visible nipples)

SD: 110 (chibi characters)

Known alterations outside of H-scenes: Kissing CG will be altered to hide facial contact / sexual suggestiveness. Heroines will be covered by towels in the bath scenes.

Availability: The game will be available for sale from Play-Asia, Mangagamer, and J-List.

Promotion: The game has received coverage from several anime and gaming blogs including Siliconera, Anime News Network and Japanator. MoeNovel will be utilizing social media to promote the game, including Facebook, Twitter, and Pinterest.

VNDB link: http://vndb.org/v9093

Official website: http://moenovel.com/imh/

PlayAsia link: http://www.play-asia...en-70-6iiv.html

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Available evidence suggests this is an initiative from the Japanese side: company based in Tokyo, awkward but grammatically correct translation, lack of advertising, no attempt to reach out to the fanbase. It's like Mangagamer's launch all over again.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Available evidence suggests this is an initiative from the Japanese side: company based in Tokyo, awkward but grammatically correct translation, lack of advertising, no attempt to reach out to the fanbase. It's like Mangagamer's launch all over again.

I guess we will have to aggregate this news to make sure that doesn't happen again.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This game sounds pretty interesting and cute, however, I'm not a big fan of the idea of removing sex scenes.

Yeah I also agree. That would destroy the entire story. They would have to modify the game and the story to do that. That's what Peach Princess did with X-Change 3 and there were issues with the changes they made.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I couldn't give the slightest fuck about H-scenes, but I think if they take them out some people won't like it. Plus in some rare cases it could hinder the story, because stuff has to be rewritten.

Anyway, as long as I don't have my own income source, I'm sadly not throwing money at things like that :/

Link to comment
Share on other sites

More information has come out on the MG forums.

http://forums.mangagamer.org/viewtopic.php?f=13&t=1390&start=10#p26632

Mangagamer will be selling it too

It was translated by 'Active Gaming Media' who also worked on Demon Souls and No More Heroes

Confirmation that it is all ages.

They are submitting it to the ESRB for review and rating.

Erotic content was removed to give it wider appeal.

The demo isn't the finalized version.

Mangagamer hints of a release in the next few days.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Erotic content was removed to give it wider appeal.

I just cannot comprehend how anyone who knows at least something about eroge would reach such idiotic conclusion that removing h-content would give "wider appeal". Didn't MG already burn on this several times and switch to nukiges exactly because they sell better than all-ages stuff? Same for minori, who nearly collapsed due to releasing all-ages shit noone cared about.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yes, it will be all-ages. We informed AGM how the visual novel audience feels about the removal of erotic content, but after discussing our advice with their client, they decided to make it all-ages in order to try and approach a wider market.

Its the stupidest excuse I've ever heard. Why couldn't they make option to auto skip H scenes or whatever or have normal and all ages version, if they really want "wider market".

What market are they targeting? If it is people who are over 18 (and actually have money), having just "skip H" option would work just fine as people who don't want H can just CTRL skip it anyway, people who want H can't CTRL add it on the other hand.

So they don't target adult audience? Who do they want to sell it to then?

Teenagers? Teenagers who

1. have much less money

2. are usually interested in JP as far as Naruto or Bleach goes, no further

3. want H scenes anyway

I really can't see what benefits are they gaining by removing the H content. Do they want lower ESRB rating? Why would you want E rated game if you sell it online anyway - people need credit cards to actually buy it. I understand all ages releases in JP where people buy it in retail stores, they can't buy 18 rated games if they are not 18. But online? You need credit card anyway so how the hell are they going to sell it to those teenagers they target? Or maybe they don't target teenagers - so why would they want lower ESRB ratings when most of the customers don't even care about it. So they maybe don't do it for the rating.

Then why?

Are they trying to target people who are strictly against any H in their moege dating sim? All 7 of them who can't just skip it if they don't want it?

And if you look at tags, it sure looks like classic dating sim, yeah it might have good story but it is about dating the girls.

Fictional Modern Day Japanese Town 2.3 Only Virgin Heroines 2.3 Dormitory 2.2 Student Club 2.2 Dormitory Manager Protagonist 2.2 Male Protagonist 2.2 Group of Friends 2.2 Airplane 2.2 Adolescent Romance 2.2 Romance 2.2 Classic Tsundere Heroine 2.2 Romancing a Family 2.0 Twin Tail Heroine 2.0 Kyonyuu Heroine 2.0 Comedy 2.0 Brother 2.0 Kouhai heroine 2.0 Osananajimi Heroine 2.0 Homecoming 2.0 Flashback 2.0 Student Heroine 2.0 Airhead Heroine 2.0 Same Roof 2.0 Genius Heroine 2.0 Senpai Heroine 2.0 Energetic Heroine 2.0 Student Club Member Protagonist 2.0 Househusband Type Protagonist 2.0 Siscon 2.0 Proactive Protagonist 2.0 Ojousama Heroine 2.0 Adult Heroine 2.0 Pettanko Heroine 2.0 Mid-game Videos 2.0 Inventor Heroine 2.0 Coodere Heroine 2.0 Crippled Heroine 2.0 Student Club Member Heroine 2.0 Transfer Student Protagonist 2.0 Twin Sister Heroines 2.0 Student Club Director Heroine 1.8 Deredere Heroine 1.7 Sister 1.7

So saying there is 7 people who want to play the game with these tags and at the same time hate H so much that they can't even stand the bother to skip it is pretty accurate.

So afte all that mentioned above, I -with my 2 years of study of logic- fail to see any logic of removing the H content from the game.

23571785.jpg

if anyone can explain what are they actually thinking and how are they benefiting from the all-ages version, please tell me. I might be extremely stupid, blind or mentally disabled because I really don't understand it.

So bottom line - no buy.

And if someone takes the translated scripts and applies them to the original version (if they don't actually change the story), I will be happy to torrent it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I never cared for H-scenes in the first place so I might buy this if there was something like a LE of the physical copy. The only reason I can think of for the censorship is them wanting break preconceptions of VNs being just mindless porn games (right MG?), though I doubt that's it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I never cared for H-scenes in the first place so I might buy this if there was something like a LE of the physical copy. The only reason I can think of for the censorship is them wanting break preconceptions of VNs being just mindless porn games (right MG?), though I doubt that's it.

Then they could have just chosen a different games that is all ages and nobody cares about, this one is full of sex and ero, cutting it is like taking half of the game away.

I mean on vndb every main char has at least 10 sexual tags, even 2 of the side characters who don't even have route have sexual tags (so there probably are H scenes in common route).

It doesn't have "low sexual content" or "late sexual content" - it has "sexual content" which often implies that the sex is there all the time, more of it in the routes. It is full romance about dating, you date and then you do your thing... while enjoying relatively good story - that's the point.

How the hell does this game work without it?

If they want to break preconceptions of VNs being just mindless porn games - release a porn game that isn't mindless (unlike MG xD) - this one would be perfect, it isn't nukige but has quite a lot of sexual content - its a good VN with everything good VN needs.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'll buy it if they fix the translation. An "awkward" translation isn't worth 35 dollars to me. More like...35 cents.

I try to avoid pornography myself, but I'm a bit surprised that they wouldn't offer both ero and non-ero for download (and both in the boxed version). It's trivial to do that with the game engine, and it makes that debate moot, right?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...