Jump to content

Why the lack of kiss CGs?


Recommended Posts

There's a difference between self-insert fantasies and real stories. The truth is, most vn's and eroge belong to the first group, hence the design choices that often neglect or entirely skip showing protagonists on the screen. I'm not talking even talking about moege or games focused on dating, since kissing there is a must so you'll have at least a single gratuitous cg somewhere.

 

Love is not just about kissing, or sex. As much as physical contact is shown on-screen, What these games often fail to portray is an actual, realistic approach to relationships - both with joys and hardships of feeling something profound towards another live being; at most these relationships between characters feel incedibly shallow and artificial. In worst cases, they just make me cringe and wonder what kind of life led the writers to create such prose.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

No, you blame the industry in general, or the fans of self-insertion.  Some people would rather imagine that the heroine is kissing them than the protag, and they're pandering to that.  If you don't do that nowadays, at least a few times, it seems to be considered strange.

 

I do that. But you see, I tried very hard to insert myself at those times and it was always unsuccessful. My brain can't understand that is a kiss. 

 

Know how it works? When the protagonist is similar to me, or I find it easier to self insert, then they show a proper kiss CG. Like Kotarou from Rewrite. (I'm SOOOOOOOOOOOOO glad they did that in Lucia's route and I'm waiting anxiously for the french kiss in the fandisc!) 

 

But I don't remember seeing any of this in LNs, though, even when they are for self-insertion too...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

There's a difference between self-insert fantasies and real stories. The truth is, most vn's and eroge belong to the first group, hence the design choices that often neglect or entirely skip showing protagonists on the screen. I'm not talking even talking about moege or games focused on dating, since kissing there is a must so you'll have at least a single gratuitous cg somewhere.

 

Because a real-life love story would be shit. Most relationships don't last in real life, so why would you want to read a romance where the main couple just ends up breaking up eventually? 

Also regarding the whole topic of kiss cgs it's import to remember most VNs don't simply have the luxury of throwing in CGs left and right, and somewhat reserve them for special scenes. Kiss CGs do exist, but most of the time they'll just have to put it in the regular character sprite so they don't have to draw up an entire CG every time the MC kisses a girl. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Most h-scenes don't show the male partner, either. At least, not clearly. Sometimes you only see their dick, sometimes you don't even see that, and a lot of the time you'll just see their back or side, with them in the corner of the screen while the girl is front and center. 

 

Basically, this and also the kissing thing is all because most VNs are pornographic eroge and the customer base likes to fap to the fantasy of themselves in these situations. If a story isn't meant to be fapped to, you're more likely to clearly see both partners kissing. 

 

Which makes me believe Eroges are fairly redundant, although one would agree that sex is a fairly important point of romance.

 

I dunno, I have always felt like I was watching the unfolding story of a group of people, rather than self inserting myself into the story. Self insertion is inheritently bad and woe be to those who have their lines between reality and fiction distorted.

 

I couldn't agree more with you. Romance IRL isn't worth reading/watching.

 

Because most of romance nowwadays is based on physical attraction, rather than what the couple lived through and experienced. Why? Because most of modern life is completely devoid of anything extraordinary.

 

Ooph, that first one though is baaaaaad.  Looks like he's trying to eat his own lips via suction.

 

 

 

You try drawing that stuff :D

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

Because a real-life love story would be shit. Most relationships don't last in real life, so why would you want to read a romance where the main couple just ends up breaking up eventually? 

Also regarding the whole topic of kiss cgs it's import to remember most VNs don't simply have the luxury of throwing in CGs left and right, and somewhat reserve them for special scenes. Kiss CGs do exist, but most of the time they'll just have to put it in the regular character sprite so they don't have to draw up an entire CG every time the MC kisses a girl. 

 

Wow, That's pretty jaded - and I say that as a man that has no interest in forming a romantic relationship with anyone,  :makina:  lol...

 

As for the kiss Cgs - I think at "least" one CG should be provided for every route - unless the reader is a complete and total boor and lacks any sort of emotional connection, a kiss is a literal embodiment of affection and love. A bond between the two.

 

But that is also subjective opinion I guess. For myself - a kiss is a very personal and symbolic thing - far deeper and meaningful then any amount of sex (though we could also get into the subject of "making love" versus "sex"). Plus, there is a huge difference between just casually kissing and "that one important kiss". a decent example being what Sarabeara posted above me.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

But that is also subjective opinion I guess. For myself - a kiss is a very personal and symbolic thing - far deeper and meaningful then any amount of sex (though we could also get into the subject of "making love" versus "sex"). Plus, there is a huge difference between just casually kissing and "that one important kiss". a decent example being what Sarabeara posted above me.

I prefer the defloration scene personally.  But I haven't run across a VN that hasn't had a kiss scene per route.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I prefer the defloration scene personally.  But I haven't run across a VN that hasn't had a kiss scene per route.

 

I "would" go for the virginity thing as another expression of closeness, if most VNs didn't turn the protag into a total pornstar during it :P I can only think of Masaya during Rise's route as being a relativly non-pornstar hscene. Call me strange - but if the mc is a virgin, I find it just a bit less silly and a little more touching when they are both obviously new to it and just sort of fumble through the motions - being rookies together and accepting that about the otehr is another type of acceptance.

 

It's true that most do have a kiss scene - but typically the protag is off screen, and the dev assumes the reader is projecting themselves as the MC. Personally, I'm the sort of reader that watches from the sidelines, I'm happy just to see the protag get along with whomever - I don't need the heroine pointing her lips at the screen, at least not for "that one important kiss" I'd rather see the two kissing, instead of her kissing my tv screen. :wahaha:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...
  • 3 weeks later...

Someone PMed me today that they are reading Dark Blue, a vn that happens to be a NTR. If a NTR VN like Dark Blue can pull off romantic kissing scenes like this, then anything that's not moege, nukige, or any kind of -ge that doesn't do self insertion/date sim should be able to pull it off. Oh, and if you add some breast fondling or fingering during the kiss scene, it is actually unbelievably hot imo. :michiru:

 

t7qmhYe.jpg
Although this is probably only 1 of the 3 romantic scenes in the game. The rest is all torture and murder.... :wahaha:
Edited by CeruleanGamer
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...