Little busters comes to mind as something with similar comedy, enjoyable cast, and tone to Majikoi. Although I do find Majikoi funnier, little busters has more dramatic elements.
Fureraba has a lot of zanny high jinks. There isn’t any supernatural magic or anything, but it is incredibly funny with a really likeable cast (Genki is one of the best comic reliefs ever)
Senren Banka is a pretty funny and interesting story about expelling a curse. Btw, I recommend Reina’s (blond big chest) route as the first you do, then go on to the others. The cast is pretty endearing and it has some interesting light drama pieces. However, it is pretty different in tone to the rest, feeling more like a zanny rural Japanese story.
Lastly, Nora to Oujo has a lot of comedy bits that remind me of Majikoi. It is probably the closest to Majikoi among these options in having constant quick comedy, supernatural elements (and even a robot coincidentally), a don’t give a crap main snarky character, and school life setting in all of its routes. Also all of the main heroines have really big boobs. Here is a clip to show what I mean: