Little busters comes to mind as something with similar comedy, enjoyable cast, and tone to Majikoi. Although I do find Majikoi funnier, little busters has more dramatic elements.
Fureraba has a lot of zanny high jinks. There isn’t any supernatural magic or anything, but it is incredibly funny with a really likeable cast (Genki is one of the best comic reliefs ever)
Senren Banka is a pretty funny and interesting story about expelling a curse. Btw, I recommend Reina’s (blond big chest) route as the first you do, then go on to the others. The cast is pretty endearing and it has some in